Money / Home loan
Payment is only the first line

Price the home as a monthly system.

Combine principal, interest, taxes, insurance and HOA—and compare loan terms by total cost.

Estimated all-in monthly cost
$2,964/mo
Principal & interest$2,124
Tax$433
Insurance / HOA$330
Cash to close$96,600

How to use this tool

Direct answer

A refinance pays off only if you stay in the home past the break-even month: closing costs divided by your monthly savings.

Three moves, one balance, very different outcomes. Enter your loan once and compare the break-even month on a refinance, the years an extra payment shaves off, the monthly cost of tapping your equity, and the cash you need to close on a new home.

What the answer includes

  • Your current balance, rate and months left — the payment you are replacing
  • The new rate and the new term you are being quoted
  • Every closing cost rolled in: origination, appraisal, title, recording, points
  • The break-even month, and the lifetime interest difference between the two loans

What can change it

  • Informational estimate. Actual rates, fees, and terms depend on the provider and contract; compare official documents before deciding.
  • Resetting a 22-year balance into a fresh 30-year loan can lower the payment and still raise your lifetime interest. Watch the total interest row, not just the payment.
  • A quoted rate is not an APR. Ask for the Loan Estimate: the APR folds in points and fees and is the only number worth comparing across lenders.
  • If you roll closing costs into the balance you are financing them at the mortgage rate for decades — the break-even is later than it looks.

Deadline or next step: a Loan Estimate is binding for 10 business days, and a rate lock usually runs 30 to 60 days — that is your real decision window.

Answer supported by: CFPB · CFPB

All amounts in U.S. dollars, all rates as annual percentages. Only the fields your case uses affect the result — leave the sample numbers in place and come back with yours.

Last reviewed:

Responsible editor:

Formula and sources verified. Educational guidance only. It does not replace qualified professional advice.

Editorial policyMethodology

Frequently asked questions

How is the break-even point on a refinance calculated?

Divide your total closing costs by the monthly payment savings, and round up. If the refinance costs $6,500 and cuts $180 off the payment, you break even at month 37 — just over three years. Stay in the home past that and the refinance pays; sell or refinance again before it and you lost the closing costs. The one nuance the simple ratio hides: if the new loan is longer than what was left on the old one, your lifetime interest can still rise even though every monthly payment is lower.

Is a lower monthly payment always a better deal?

No, and this is the most expensive misunderstanding in mortgage lending. Stretching a balance with 22 years left back out over 30 years lowers the payment purely by adding 96 more payments. The breakdown here shows total interest under both loans side by side. If total interest goes up, you are buying monthly cash flow with lifetime cost — a legitimate trade when money is tight, but you should know you are making it.

What rate drop makes a refinance worth doing?

There is no universal threshold — the old "one full point" rule of thumb ignores loan size. What matters is the break-even month against how long you plan to stay. On a large balance, half a point can break even in under two years; on a small balance, even two full points may never pay off the closing costs. Run your own numbers rather than trusting a rule.

How much does an extra payment actually save?

More than people expect, because an extra dollar of principal cancels every future interest charge that dollar would have generated. On a $320,000 balance at 6.8% with 27 years left, an extra $200 a month typically shortens the loan by roughly five years and saves tens of thousands in interest. The effect is front-loaded: the same $200 started ten years from now saves far less.

Should I pay extra on the mortgage or invest instead?

Paying down a mortgage is a guaranteed, risk-free return equal to your rate — a 6.8% loan is a 6.8% return you cannot lose. Investing may beat it over long horizons but is not guaranteed. The usual ordering is: employer 401(k) match first (it is an instant 50%–100% return), then high-rate consumer debt, then the mortgage versus taxable investing question. Keep an emergency fund either way, because principal you send to the servicer is not money you can get back without borrowing it again.

What is the difference between a HELOC and a home equity loan?

A home equity loan is a lump sum at a fixed rate with a fixed payment from day one. A HELOC is a revolving line: you draw what you need during a draw period (often 10 years) paying interest only, then it converts to a repayment period (often 20 years) where principal is added and the payment jumps. HELOCs are usually variable-rate, tied to the prime rate, so the payment can move even before the draw period ends.

How much can I borrow with a HELOC?

Lenders work from a combined loan-to-value limit: the maximum they will let your first mortgage plus the line reach, as a share of the home value. At an 85% limit on a $450,000 home with a $320,000 mortgage, the ceiling is $450,000 × 85% − $320,000 = $62,500. That is a lending convention, not a rule of law, which is why it is an editable field here — your lender may cap at 80% or stretch to 90%.

Why does my HELOC payment jump so much later?

Because during the draw period you are only paying the interest, so the balance never moves. When repayment begins, the same balance has to be fully amortized over the remaining years, so principal is suddenly added to every payment. On a $60,000 line the interest-only payment might be around $300 while the repayment payment is closer to $430 — and if the variable rate has risen in the meantime, more still. The breakdown shows both figures and the size of the jump.

How much cash do I need to buy a home?

Down payment plus closing costs. Closing costs commonly run 2% to 5% of the price and cover lender fees, appraisal, title insurance and search, recording, and prepaid items such as the first year of homeowners insurance and the property tax escrow cushion. On a $450,000 purchase with 10% down and 3% costs, that is $45,000 plus $13,500 — about $58,500 before you have bought a single piece of furniture.

Do I have to put 20% down?

No. Conventional loans go down to 3% for qualified buyers, FHA to 3.5%, and VA and USDA loans to zero for those eligible. What 20% buys you is the avoidance of private mortgage insurance on a conventional loan. PMI is not permanent: you can generally request cancellation once you reach 20% equity, and it terminates automatically at 22% under the Homeowners Protection Act.

Is mortgage interest still deductible?

Interest on acquisition debt secured by your main or second home is deductible if you itemize, within the limits set by the tax code, and interest on a home equity loan or HELOC is deductible only when the proceeds are used to buy, build, or substantially improve the home securing the loan. Because the standard deduction is large, most households do not itemize and therefore get no deduction at all. Check the current IRS guidance for the year you are filing before you count on it.

How does rent-to-own compare with buying outright?

In a rent-to-own or lease-option contract, only the rent credit explicitly written into the agreement counts toward the eventual purchase — typically a slice of an above-market rent — and it is usually forfeited if you do not or cannot exercise the option. You also normally pay a non-refundable option fee up front. Compare the total of option fee plus credited rent against a straightforward down payment before assuming it is the cheaper path in.

Editorial transparency

Who is responsible for this page

Editorial status explained in methodology
Author and responsible editorFounder and responsible editor of Hacé Cuentas.
How it is checkedAuthorship and methodology are explained on our editorial pages.
Sources and methodThis page explains its assumptions and limitations.View methodology →

Choose your situation

Main query:Refinance, pay extra, or take a HELOC? Run all three on your mortgage

What do you want to solve?

Related tools in other countries and languages

Check the language, units and assumptions of each tool.